Analysis of Matsya Avatar & Noahs Ark 4,000 years ago

21-02-2019 21:22 MonsoonLady#11
Quote
Originally Posted by Asiansoul »

Well researched post!!

If the ark was 4,000 years ago , would that explain the Harappan floods?

Quote

The Indus civilisation is also known as the Harappan Civilisation, after its type site, Harappa, the first of its sites to be excavated early in the 20th century in what was then the Punjab province of British India and now is Pakistan.[9][e] The discovery of Harappa and soon afterwards Mohenjo-daro was the culmination of work beginning in 1861 with the founding of the Archaeological Survey of India during the British Raj

- Wright, Rita P. (2009). The Ancient Indus: Urbanism, Economy, and Society. Cambridge University Press. ISBN 978-0-521-57219-4. Retrieved 29 September 2013.


Harappan floods did not destroy the whole of India.
30-11-2020 17:51 Neha.Kulkarni#12
Finally done it!!

Made my video from most of the notes

please shareeeeeee!!

#DavidWood #NoahsArk #Hinduism
Proud Hindu: 3 reasons why Christianity is false?

07-12-2020 11:54 MsTee1985#13
Hardly makes any sense :S

How did domestic cats and dogs evolve within a time span of 5,000 years? 8-)
07-12-2020 11:55 MsTee1985#14
Quote
Originally Posted by Neha.Kulkarni »

Finally done it!!

Made my video from most of the notes

please shareeeeeee!!

#DavidWood #NoahsArk #Hinduism
Proud Hindu: 3 reasons why Christianity is false?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XnXH1yZrYZo&t=18s

Video is too long but fantastic!

I'm trying to share the notes
13-12-2020 23:35 Neha.Kulkarni#15
Quote
Originally Posted by MsTee1985 »

Hardly makes any sense :S

How did domestic cats and dogs evolve within a time span of 5,000 years? 8-)

Here is a copy of my notes (H)


i have read a Christian apologist book, where they explain that not every specie was required...For example, cats are descendants from lions , tigers...so their theory is, they took the primary source, which later evolved over time.. LoL.., now we know, that majority of species have evolved, mutaed over 1,000s of years to be what they are today...where as the floods happen 4,000 years ago..So a house cat evolving from a lion would not be possible in 3,000 years (38 species of cats on the planet)
I have a copy of the book, I will take a picture and upload it ;p



Quote

The pantherlike ancestor to the cat family first appeared in Southeast Asia, about 10.8 million years ago. Prior to the use of DNA studies in cats, it was difficult to trace the Felidae family history, because feline fossils are rare, and difficult to tell apart.

In 1997, Warren E. Johnson and Stephen J. O’Brien performed DNA analyses of 37 living cat species, which allowed them to divide today’s cats into 8 lineages.

The great roaring cats (lions, leopards, jaguars, tigers) were the first to branch off, about 6.4 million years ago. The ancestor of modern domestic cats was the last to appear, about 3.4 million years ago. A small wildcat species was first domesticated in the Near East 8,000 to 10,000 years ago.

As sea levels rose and fell, cats migrated to new continents and developed new species. It is estimated that cats migrated to North America from Asia across the Bering land bridge connecting Siberia and Alaska about 9 million years ago. Later, several American cat lineages returned to Asia. With each migration, the cats evolved further and changed into an ever-growing array of sizes and types of felines. Based on the DNA and fossil evidence, the Johnnson-O’Brien team was able to demonstrate a series of at least 10 intercontinental migrations of cats over the past 10 million years, in which cat were able to colonize the world.

Written by Tiffany Lennox, DVM

References:
Scientific American 297, 68-75 (2007)

https://www.killarneycat.com/the-evo...%20years%20ago.
18-12-2020 03:10 ---RuFfEdGe---#16
That was explained good!

I found the video easy to follow but the writing for some of the books was unclear
if you have the pdf or screens please upload them
29-12-2020 22:54 MonsoonLady#17
So how long ago was the Matsya avataar? You still have not said :S
23-06-2021 13:18 Neha.Kulkarni#18
Quote
Originally Posted by MonsoonLady »

So how long ago was the Matsya avataar? You still have not said :S

I've only read this now..I was searching for this thread to pass the link onto someone I was discussing Adams age...I will post my notes here....I used method two as Kal suggested:

The 4 time cycles, in Hinduism (which you should already know from ) are:

Satya 1,728,000
Treta 1,296,000
Dvapara 864,000
Kalyuga 432,000

Matsya avatar took place in Satya Yuga , which is 1,728,000 years ago ..Now compare that to "4,000" years ago.

Noahs ark took place 4,000 years ago.

There is no comparison. Its is possible for life to evolve from Satya yuga but not when Noah or Adam walked the earth 4,000 or 8,000 years ago..It is basic common sense.

So, if someone says Hinduism also contains the great floods , first they need to understand the 4 time cycles.

We are currently living in Kalyug.

I will make a second video of this, to break down the first 10 generations of Adam and the 4 yugas.
29-06-2021 10:22 Inthemix#19
Quote
Originally Posted by Asiansoul »

Well researched post!!

If the ark was 4,000 years ago , would that explain the Harappan floods?

Quote

The Indus civilisation is also known as the Harappan Civilisation, after its type site, Harappa, the first of its sites to be excavated early in the 20th century in what was then the Punjab province of British India and now is Pakistan.[9][e] The discovery of Harappa and soon afterwards Mohenjo-daro was the culmination of work beginning in 1861 with the founding of the Archaeological Survey of India during the British Raj

- Wright, Rita P. (2009). The Ancient Indus: Urbanism, Economy, and Society. Cambridge University Press. ISBN 978-0-521-57219-4. Retrieved 29 September 2013.

Harappan floods is nothing but guess work :S

Quote

Was there a war?
Some historians believed the Indus civilisation was destroyed in a large war. Hindu poems called the Rig Veda (from around 1500 BC) describe northern invaders conquering the Indus Valley cities.

In the 1940s, archaeologist Mortimer Wheeler discovered 39 human skeletons at Mohenjo-Daro. He believed that they were people killed by invaders.

Archaeologists now think this is not true. There is no evidence of war or mass killings. Indus Valley people seem to have been peaceful. If they had an army, they have left few signs of weapons or battles.

It's more likely that the cities collapsed after natural disasters. Enemies might have moved in afterwards.

Source for the above: https://www.bbc.co.uk/bitesize/topic...ticles/z8b987h


Vedas are not 1500 BC (N)
How can Vedas be 1500BC WHEN Mahabharat and the Bhagavad Gita is 5,000 years old?
08-07-2021 09:44 Desi_0_0_Doll#20
Quote
Originally Posted by Kalpana.v »


This made so much sense. I was told Matsya avtaar took place the same time as Noahs ark (when I was 9 Lol)


My brainwashed cousin from India told me Manu and Noah are the same...I was wth are you talking about? She got offended that I was trying to cause "communal disharmony"..

She said we are all the same , we pray to the same god 8-)

I thought...Yeh, right!!!

I told her: 3 gods from 3 religions want to throw us in hell for rejecting them and OUR god allows freedom of worship and Manus legend is much older..I felt sad she was defending something she has not even read +o(